Prosecutors in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s criminal trial will be allowed to cross-examine former attorney-general Avichai Mandelblit after defense lawyers withdrew their objection on Wednesday, easing restrictions that prompted an unusual prosecution petition to the High Court of Justice this week.
The Jerusalem District Court said the arrangement would apply going forward to witnesses called by the defense, whether or not they had originally appeared on the prosecution’s witness list. The judges expressly included Mandelblit, whose testimony has focused on his authorization of the investigations into Netanyahu and the indictment.
But the change did not immediately end the dispute before the High Court. Defense lawyers asked for the petition to be struck out and Sunday’s hearing canceled, while prosecutors sought clarification of the law, arguing that the District Court’s earlier rulings could affect other criminal trials.
Supreme Court President Isaac Amit directed the state to say by noon on Thursday whether it was maintaining its petition.
Presiding Judge Rivka Friedman-Feldman and Judges Moshe Bar-Am and Oded Shaham said the defense had changed its position for practical and procedural reasons while maintaining its legal arguments. They would proceed accordingly, the judges wrote, without changing their earlier decisions concerning witnesses who had already testified.
Netanyahu’s lawyer, Amit Hadad, said prosecutors could question Mandelblit as they wished, while the defense would continue to object to individual questions.
“Let them question him to their heart’s content; we will object to specific questions,” he said.
Jacques Chen, who represents codefendants Shaul and Iris Elovitch, also agreed to prosecution cross-examination, saying the recurring dispute was consuming time and disrupting the trial.
In a subsequent filing with the High Court, Chen argued that the change made the requested remedies entirely unnecessary. The filing, submitted on behalf of the Elovitches with the agreement of Netanyahu and fellow defendant Arnon “Noni” Mozes, asked the court to strike out the petition and cancel the November 22 hearing.
Prosecutors seek broader High Court ruling on witness questioning in Netanyahu trial
Prosecutors, however, said their petition also sought to settle the legal question beyond Netanyahu’s trial. They warned that leaving the earlier rulings intact could affect how prosecutors draw up witness lists and decide which witnesses they can forgo calling as proceedings advance.
The concern was already arising in practice, they argued: defendants in other criminal cases had cited the rulings to seek similar restrictions on prosecution questioning.
The state therefore asked the High Court to clarify that the District Court’s decision to leave its earlier rulings unchanged meant only that witnesses already questioned would not be recalled, rather than preserving the legal basis for restricting prosecution cross-examination.
The disagreement concerned who gets to ask what when a witness takes the stand.
Ordinarily, the side calling a witness questions them first, and the opposing side then cross-examines them. Cross-examination allows leading questions and challenges to the witness’s account. Re-examination, which follows, is generally confined to clarifying matters raised in cross-examination.
During the defense stage, Netanyahu’s lawyers have called witnesses, including investigators, whom prosecutors had listed but ultimately did not summon. The defense has sought to use their testimony to establish alleged flaws in the investigation.
The court allowed the defense to cross-examine these witnesses while restricting the prosecution’s subsequent questioning. The dispute extended to Mandelblit, who had not appeared on the prosecution’s witness list.
Prosecutors argued that calling him as a defense witness entitled them to cross-examine him, regardless of his former position as head of the prosecution. They said the restrictions prevented them from effectively addressing gaps and contradictions concerning events roughly a decade ago.
The state petitioned the High Court on Monday against the November 2 decision concerning Mandelblit, seeking a broader ruling on its right to cross-examine defense witnesses. Intervention in interim decisions during a criminal trial is exceptional; prosecutors argued that waiting until an appeal against a final judgment could cause harm that would be difficult to repair.
On Tuesday, the High Court issued a conditional order requiring respondents to explain why the requested relief should not be granted. A hearing was set for Sunday before Amit and Justices Yael Willner and Khaled Kabub. The court declined interim relief.
Mandelblit’s questioning by the defense has not finished. His testimony was interrupted after additional material concerning his investigation approvals was disclosed to the defense, and the court has since ordered further disclosure.
Attorney-General Baharav-Miara summoned to discuss Netanyahu trial proceedings
Separately, Attorney-General Gali Baharav-Miara is due before the trial panel on November 25, after the prosecution requested a one-week postponement. The judges summoned her to discuss how to manage the proceedings and move them forward.
That discussion follows repeated efforts to shorten the trial, which began in May 2020. In June, the panel ordered hearings expanded to five days a week from October 4, ahead of Friedman-Feldman’s expected retirement in March 2028.
In June, the judges also reiterated their 2023 assessment that there were difficulties proving bribery in Case 4000 and suggested prosecutors reconsider the charge. The prosecution has maintained it; the judges’ comments were not a verdict.
Herzog seeks talks on agreed resolution before deciding Netanyahu pardon request
President Isaac Herzog has separately sought talks toward an agreed resolution before deciding on Netanyahu’s presidential pardon request. In a September interview with Channel 13, he said he was leaving the door open to the initiative.
Last week, prosecutor Yehudit Tirosh reiterated that Baharav-Miara and State Attorney Amit Aisman remained open to direct discussions. The prosecution had accepted Herzog’s invitation, while Netanyahu had not responded, she told the court.
The proceedings continue alongside coalition negotiations following the October 27 election, with Yashar leader Gadi Eisenkot tasked with forming a government and Netanyahu’s political future still unsettled.
Netanyahu faces fraud and breach-of-trust charges in all three cases, and bribery in Case 4000, where prosecutors allege he advanced regulatory measures benefiting Bezeq in exchange for intervention in Walla's coverage. Cases 1000 and 2000 concern, respectively, gifts from wealthy businessmen and alleged dealings with publisher Mozes over newspaper coverage. He denies wrongdoing.