For about 10 years, I have warned that American Jews face the possibility of another Holocaust. The anti-Israel demonstrations across dozens of US campuses and cities over the past three years have only strengthened my conviction.
Until now, I expressed this warning privately. The time has come to put it in writing.
As a Holocaust remembrance educator with 20 years of experience leading delegations to Poland, I compare developments in the United States with those in Europe during the 1930s.
In March 2024, Franklin Foer published an article in The Atlantic titled "The Golden Age of American Jews Is Ending." His argument reinforced my concerns, but I believe this golden age may end not quietly, but in blood and fire.
My fears became certainty with Donald Trump's election in 2016. Trump may be the best American president Israel has ever had, but he is also unpredictable, unfaithful to the truth, and willing to encourage extremist forces. His conduct surrounding the January 6, 2021, Capitol attack demonstrated the danger.
If someone with Trump's background and behavior can be elected president twice, what prevents Americans from electing someone resembling Hitler?
The Democratic Party offers little reassurance. American Jews traditionally supported Democrats because the party defended religious minorities and oppressed communities. Yet an emerging coalition of liberals, socialists, and Islamist activists increasingly portrays Jews as part of the oppressive establishment.
In Germany's 1933 elections, Hitler's Nazi Party won 43.9% of the vote. Hitler formed a coalition with the German National People's Party and rapidly consolidated power.
Anyone who believes something similar could never happen in the world's largest democracy should reconsider.
American history provides troubling precedents. In February 1939, thousands attended a pro-Nazi rally organized by the German-American Bund at Madison Square Garden.
The US entered World War II only after Japan attacked Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941, not because of Nazi aggression against European Jews.
Throughout the war, American aircraft bombed industrial facilities near Auschwitz-Birkenau but never directly targeted its gas chambers. Appeals to bomb the extermination facilities or railway tracks were rejected, with officials arguing that winning the war would save the Jews.
During summer 1944, approximately 430,000 Hungarian Jews were murdered at Birkenau while Allied aircraft attacked industrial targets nearby.
American refugee policy was equally devastating. The 1943 Bermuda Conference failed to open America's doors to Jews fleeing Nazi persecution. State Department officials, including Cordell Hull and Breckinridge Long, helped maintain restrictions that left desperate refugees without sanctuary.
The St. Louis, carrying Jewish refugees, was refused entry to North America in 1939 and forced back to Europe, where many passengers eventually perished.
Are American Jews truly safe in their homeland? I believe they are not.
Israel faces enormous dangers, but I believe it will endure. Whether Israel could rescue American Jews across the Atlantic during a future catastrophe is another question entirely.
Warning signs from history
The similarities between American Jewry today and European Jewry before the Holocaust are striking.
Between the world wars, German Jews felt deeply rooted in their country. They identified with German culture and contributed disproportionately to its economy, universities, science and arts.
German-Jewish economist Franz Oppenheimer wrote to his wife in 1913, "Good thing we are Germans."
Jews represented approximately half a percent of Prussia's population, yet around 40 of its 200 wealthiest families were Jewish. In Berlin, Jews comprised 5% of residents but paid more than 30% of municipal taxes.
Jewish contributions to German cultural life were similarly extraordinary. Jewish writers, musicians, scientists and academics helped shape the country's intellectual achievements. Their success did not prevent the Nazis from stripping them of their rights.
Polish Jews likewise considered Poland their home. Warsaw had more than 400 synagogues, while Vilna had approximately 100 houses of prayer. Jewish communities supported a flourishing Yiddish press, publishing dozens of daily, weekly and monthly newspapers.
Jewish financiers and entrepreneurs helped develop Poland's banks, industries, mines and factories.
Despite antisemitism, many European Jews believed their economic success, cultural contributions and sense of belonging guaranteed their future.
They could not imagine the catastrophe approaching.
American Jewry today occupies an equally prominent position.
Jewish entrepreneurs helped establish Hollywood. Sergey Brin helped found Google, Mark Zuckerberg founded Facebook, and Sam Altman became a leading figure in artificial intelligence.
Jewish families such as Goldman, Lehman, Warburg, Schiff and Seligman played major roles in American finance.
Jewish connections also extend into America's political leadership, including the families of Donald Trump, Joe Biden and Kamala Harris.
American Jews achieved extraordinary prosperity, influence and integration. Yet the demonstrations following October 7, 2023, exposed how fragile that security could be.
At elite universities and in New York's streets, protesters chanted "free Palestine from the river to the sea." Jewish Americans suddenly encountered hostility in places they had considered their own.
The political rise of figures such as Zohran Mamdani, Abdul El-Sayed and Ilhan Omar has further intensified my concerns about America's direction.
It is time to reconsider our future.
What can be done?
Israel's government and the Jewish Agency must establish a national program to accommodate the immigration of American Jews.
Such immigration should not be considered a burden. On the contrary, it could become Israel's salvation.
Imagine hundreds of thousands of American Jews moving to Israel with their capital, businesses, professional expertise and financial resources.
They could invest in Israel's economy, strengthen its defenses and establish new cities throughout the Negev and Galilee, creating infrastructure capable of eventually accommodating millions of immigrants.
This could transform Israel's future following October 7, strengthening both the country and the Jews seeking refuge within it.
History shows that catastrophe does not arrive overnight.
German Jews endured years of persecution before the "Final Solution." Polish Jews experienced economic boycotts, attacks on Jewish university students, and eventually segregated "ghetto benches" imposed by academic institutions.
Does this sound familiar?
Most Poles were not murderers, but many stood aside as Jews were persecuted and deported.
Most Americans are not bad people either. Yet I fear that when extremists from the radical Right and Left unite against Jews, bystanders will again fail to intervene.
Those who marched immediately after October 7, 2023, declaring "By any means necessary," demonstrated how readily some people could justify horrific violence against Jews.
My American Jewish brothers and sisters: We must learn from history rather than assume it cannot repeat itself.
We will not forget!
The time to act is now, before it is too late.